What is Ethical/ ESG Investing?
Ethical investing or ‘ESG’ investing means different things to different people and the terms ‘sustainable investing’ or ‘responsible investing’ can also be used interchangeably.
Broadly it is just a way of investing your money in a way that represents your ethical stance/ values on issues. Investors may have sustainable preferences and ethics is very personal to everyone. These may be also influenced by a person’s habits and lifestyle.
Investors may have things they support or things they want to avoid. For some it is about making sure their kids and grandchildren inherit a friendly climate and a socially and economically cohesive world. For some it is about avoiding the ‘Sin Stocks’ such as a gambling and alcohol. For others it is about making sure that they are not investing in unstainable practices or oppressive labour conditions.
How can I be sure that the investments are Ethical?
This can be a challenging question.
Where do we start and how can we be confident in the outcomes sought?
Addressing ethical concerns is important for most modern corporations. This can be lip service via a marketing strategy but little real action (or ‘greenwashing’), or it can be more deeply ingrained in a corporate culture by setting real world goals and aligning a company’s future direction to meet and improve Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) focused standards.
The fund manager Pengana, notes that across the major companies to invest in on major global share market indices, there are:
- Sustainable Growth Businesses: who are already good corporate citizens and provided sustainable growth with good ESG characteristics (perhaps 15 % of global companies),
- Transitioning businesses – who are moving in the right direction and getting tailwinds of broader ESG trends. They are moving towards better ESG practices and are being pushed by a demand for greater transparency from regulators, large investors and other stakeholders (perhaps 70% of global companies),
- Businesses at risk– who are not demonstrating progress towards better ESG practices (perhaps 15% of global businesses).
When investing in ethical funds it can be a bit of a leap of faith. Just because a fund has Ethical or Sustainable in the title it doesn’t mean that there may still not be investments that an individual may consider questionable or does not support.
For this reason, a good ethical fund has to provide the investor the ability to easily drill down into the detail of the investments and the underlying companies to see what they are investing in and the tangible effects which a resulting across a range of ethical outcomes.
Is the performance competitive?
All investments have risk levels and returns roughly correlate with the level of risk you want to take.
An ethical investment strategy by its nature is quite hands on. Not that the investor is expected to do this as its complicated and time-consuming work. This means the strategy of ‘Active ‘investing to achieve the desired outcomes. Active investing necessarily costs more in investment fee’s than a ‘passive’ approach. This is the first consideration.
A good ethical fund will set performance goals, which normally means comparing themselves against a benchmark index. Benchmarking uses a standard reference point to compare similar investments over time.
Third, ethical investing does not have to be speculative. Strong fundamentals and economic outlook, which are the normal basis for expected returns, should be an important part of the initial and ongoing research that a fund does into its underlying assets.
Ideally the fund will provide feedback to the companies in its basket on the key areas in which they are performing well, or where they can provide improvement. This increases the cultural move towards better ethical outcomes and strengthening the base of successful companies in this space.
It should be lastly noted that there are ‘impact’ ethical funds who were not only filter out certain companies – but also actively invest in ones that are providing sustainable growth and also seek to influence company boards and their decisions.
Do I have to be 100% in ethical investments?
Not at all. This depends on your appetite for investment risk and how important this is to you.
Having just a portion of your investments invested ethically can provide necessary diversity across your portfolio but may also help to achieve future outcomes you are aiming to achieve.
The more investment that goes into ethical funding, the greater the market share becomes, the more both the value and performance of ethical funds may improve. This provides the impetus for companies at large to invest ethically and makes it a stronger sector.
You can start the snowball effect. Already there is a growing awareness in the business world that Future Environmental risks could erode returns on conventional investments and so ESG considerations are important.
Summary
In summary, ethical/ESG investing can be tailored to your desired outcomes.
It can be the overarching theme or guiding force over your whole investment strategy or can be complimentary part of a broader investment portfolio.
For some investors it is seen as an important long-term strategy for themselves, their family and to try and make a difference to the world.
At Chapters Retirement Partners- we can integrate ethical/ ESG investment strategies within major super funds and investment platforms.
If you are interested in how ethical/ ESG investments could be integrated into your investment or superannuation portfolio and in a way that still aligns with your broader financial goals- please get in touch with our team.